Somewhere in your booking system, your ordering platform or your point of sale, there’s a list of people who have already chosen your business. They came in, they ate or bought something, and at some point they gave you their email address.
Most independent venues and shops have hundreds of these people, and plenty have thousands. Most never send them anything.
It’s easy to leave alone because it never shows up as a cost. There’s no bill for the customer who would have come back if someone had reminded them.
Going quiet costs more than you’d think
When a customer has a good experience and never hears from you again, their next visit is left to chance. Maybe they walk past on the right day. Maybe they see a post. Maybe they end up somewhere else because another venue’s email landed first.
People don’t usually stop coming because something went wrong. They stop because life’s busy and nobody reminded them.
Email is the one channel where you can reach those people directly. There’s no algorithm deciding who sees it and no paying to boost it. It goes to their inbox with your name on it.
What a working list looks like
The difference shows up in the numbers you already watch: midweek bookings, whether a special night fills, how often regulars come back. At Jordy’s in Casuarina, where I write and send the emails every week, this is what changed.
Jordy’s real numbers from NowBookIt and TalkBox. Booked covers only, so walk-ins aren’t counted.
It also changes how people feel about you. The people on your list hear about things first. They see the new menu before it’s on Instagram. They start to feel like regulars, and regulars behave like regulars.
Why it doesn’t get started
Most owners know they should be doing it. What stops them is that email sounds technical: platform setup, domain authentication, segments, automated flows. It’s enough to make anyone close the laptop and get back to the floor.
Most of that is set-up work you do once. After that, the automated emails go out on their own: a welcome when someone new joins, a birthday email, a win back for someone who hasn’t been in for a couple of months. The weekly or fortnightly campaign is the part that needs someone to write it.
A rough way to work out what it’s worth
Take the number of people on your list. Think about how many might come in if you sent them something worth reading this week, even a small share of them. Multiply that by your average spend. It’s rough, but it gives you an idea of what’s sitting in your system doing nothing.
Where to start
Find out where your list lives and how many people are on it. I work in Klaviyo and Mailchimp, and with booking systems like NowBookIt and TalkBox, so there’s a good chance whatever you’re using already has what you need.