Journal·Websites

Your website might be losing you customers, and you won’t see which ones

Most small business websites look fine at a glance. The customers they lose leave no trace. Here’s where it usually happens, and how to check yours.

Some losses don’t feel like losses. There’s no complaint, no bad review and no awkward phone call. Just someone who looked at your website, found it hard work and went somewhere else.

Because nothing tells you it happened, most owners don’t know. They notice that enquiries feel a bit low, or that the place down the road always seems busier.

People compare you to every other site they use

Nobody lands on your website fresh. They’ve just come from apps and sites that are quick and easy on a phone, and that’s the standard they bring with them.

They aren’t being fussy when they leave a page that takes ages to load, a menu that’s a scanned PDF, or a contact page they can’t find. They just go back and tap the next result. It costs them nothing.

It rarely looks broken

Most small business websites look fine at a glance. There are photos, some words, a menu or a list of services, contact details. The problems are in the details:

  • A booking button that goes to a page nobody has checked in two years
  • Opening hours that changed and never got updated
  • A menu that downloads as a file instead of opening on the page
  • Google showing different hours to the website
  • A list of services that stopped being accurate when the business moved on

Any one of these might only cost you the odd customer. Together, over a year, they add up, and because none of them is obvious, fixing them never feels urgent.

Being found comes first

Before anyone can be put off by your website, they have to find it. When someone searches for a café, a plasterer or a mortgage broker near them, Google decides who to show. It looks at how your site is structured, how quickly it loads, whether your Google Business Profile is complete, and whether the words on your pages match what people are searching for.

A lot of small business websites were built to look good rather than to be found, and those are different jobs. A site that doesn’t come up in local searches can look lovely and still bring in very little, because the people it’s meant for never see it.

The business moves on and the website doesn’t

A website that was fine when it launched slowly drifts out of date. Services change, prices change, the team changes and the photos get older. The business has moved on, and the website is still describing the old one.

It’s worth treating it like the front of your shop. You’d fix a door that sticks or a sign with the wrong hours straight away. The online version is just harder to notice.

Look at it the way a stranger would

You can’t count the people who left. What you can do is open your website on your phone, as if you’d never heard of the business, and ask three things:

  • Can I tell what they do within a few seconds?
  • Do they look like they’re good at it?
  • Is it obvious how to book, order or get a quote?

If any of those take effort, that’s where people are leaving.

← Back to the journal

Start here

Send me your website.

Add a line about your business, and your photos or a recent email if you like. I’ll tell you what I’d fix first. I read and reply to every one myself.

Get your site reviewed